Toronto 2012: The promise, pitfalls of potential Oscar contenders - Los Angeles Times
Advertisement

Toronto 2012: The promise, pitfalls of potential Oscar contenders

Share via

“The Artist” played there. So did “The King’s Speech.” In fact, six of the past seven best picture Oscar winners gained awards-season momentum at the Toronto International Film Festival, which launches Thursday. One, “The Hurt Locker,” even found a distributor there.

How will this year’s contenders fare? We chart the potential for promise and pitfalls among some of the higher-profile titles screening there over the next 10 days.

ARGO

Advertisement

Premise: CIA agents pose as film crew to rescue U.S. diplomats in Tehran during the 1979 Iran hostage crisis.

Pedigree: Director Ben Affleck’s two previous efforts were both well-regarded Oscar bridesmaids. Cast includes Oscar winner Alan Arkin, small-screen awards magnets Bryan Cranston, Kyle Chandler.

Best case: Talk of Affleck the auteur deepens. Voters embrace thriller’s hooray-for-Hollywood comic elements.

Advertisement

Worst case: Talk of Affleck needing to stick to Beantown genre projects deepens. Affleck’s Seventies-style haircut draws bigger laughs than Arkin.

ANNA KARENINA

Premise: Forlorn wife (Keira Knightley) of aristocrat begins hot-and-heavy affair with dashing cavalry officer in latest adaptation of the great Tolstoy novel.

Advertisement

Pedigree: Previous collaborations between director Joe Wright and Knightley — “Pride and Prejudice,” “Atonement” — have found favor. Tom Stoppard writing the screenplay doesn’t hurt.

Best case: Film’s single-setting conceit puts revelatory new spin on familiar material.

Worst case: Critics spend more time carping about what was cut from the book than praising what’s on the screen.

CLOUD ATLAS

Premise: Six interwoven tales set in past, present, future reveal truths about the human condition.

Pedigree: Filmmakers (Lana and Andy Wachowski, Tom Tykwer) known for infusing spectacle with deep thoughts. Cast full of Oscar perennials: Tom Hanks, Halle Berry, Jim Broadbent.

Best case: Audiences find movie both a thrilling ride and an illumination of the nature of reality.

Advertisement

Worst case: Audiences remain hopelessly confused by film’s tricky narrative structure.

HYDE PARK ON HUDSON

Premise: Bill Murray plays Franklin Delano Roosevelt in a slice of history set as the president meets England’s King George VI on the eve of WWII.

Pedigree: Murray’s lone Oscar nomination: “Lost in Translation.” Co-star Laura Linney, playing FDR’s distant cousin and confidante, owns three Oscar noms.

Best case: Murray forced to grudgingly return to Oscar ceremony. Might even be seen clapping.

Worst case: Film overshadowed by season’s other presidential portrait, Steven Spielberg’s “Lincoln.”

THE MASTER

Advertisement

Premise: Alcoholic drifter (Joaquin Phoenix) forms complicated relationship with the leader (Philip Seymour Hoffman) of a fledgling spiritual movement.

Pedigree: Hoffman won lead actor Oscar for “Capote” in 2005, the same year Phoenix was nominated for “Walk the Line.” Writer-director Paul Thomas Anderson is a five-time nominee.

Best case: Weinstein marketing magic makes movie a must-see event; audience response matches critical hosannas.

Worst case: Talk centers on L. Ron Hubbard’s beliefs rather than Anderson’s artistry.

THE SESSIONS

Premise: Journalist/poet (John Hawkes) hires therapeutic sex surrogate (Helen Hunt) to help with virginity issues.

Pedigree: Hawkes won nom for “Winter’s Bone” baddie; co-star Hunt took Oscar 15 years ago for “As Good as It Gets.”

Advertisement

Best case: Film continues to build on Sundance raves, where it took two prizes. Hawkes and Hunt solidify places in Oscar races.

Worst case: Pic’s lack of visual panache detracts from performances. Buzz focuses more on revelations of skin than character.

SILVER LININGS PLAYBOOK

Premise: Football-obsessed former high school teacher (Bradley Cooper) leaves mental health facility, partners with eccentric neighbor (Jennifer Lawrence) to win back ex-wife (Brea Bree).

Pedigree: Writer-director David O. Russell’s last movie, “The Fighter,” won six nominations, including nods for pic and director and a win for Christian Bale.

Best case: Russell succeeds in fashioning an emotionally accessible adaptation of the quirky source material. Cooper and Lawrence dazzle; Robert De Niro, playing Cooper’s dad, reasserts acting chops.

Advertisement

Worst case: Russell succeeds in fashioning a fascinating adaptation ... but it divides audiences a la his “I Heart Huckabees.”

TO THE WONDER

Premise: Romantic drama about a man (Ben Affleck) reconnecting with hometown sweetheart (Rachel McAdams) after marriage to a Parisian woman (Olga Kurylenko) goes kaput.

Pedigree: It’s Terrence Malick’s shockingly fast follow-up to “The Tree of Life,” which scored Oscar noms for picture and director just last year.

Best case: The currently unsold film wows audiences and wins a passionate distributor eager to put promotional muscle behind the movie, be it this year or next.

Worst case: People complain that Malick makes too many movies.

ALSO:

Advertisement

Oscar 8-Ball: Wes Anderson’s ‘Moonrise Kingdom’

For your consideration: Meryl Streep in ‘Hope Springs’

New “Master” trailer: The rhythm of the saints ... and sinners

Advertisement